
In this series of Policy Perspectives, ADVOCACYDENVER is providing synopses of meetings of the Colorado Commission on Medicaid. This edition covers the meeting held on November 10, 2026. The Colorado Commission on Medicaid is working toward the goal of creating a sustainable Medicaid program for the state. The Commission will present their final report to the General Assembly and Governor in December.
Agenda & Materials:
The meeting agenda and materials can be found HERE.
Recording of the meeting can be found HERE.
Present for this Meeting:
- Senator Judy Amabile (D), Chair
- Representative Kyle Brown (D), Vice Chair
- Representative Carlos Barron (R)
- Senator Jeff Bridges (D)
- Senator Lisa Frizell (R)
- Representative Lindsay Gilchrist (D)
- Senator Barbara Kirkmeyer (R)
- Senator Kyle Mullica (D)
- Representative Emily Sirota (D)
- Representative Rick Taggart (R)
Facilitator: Summer Gathercole
The Commission closely followed a slide deck for this meeting. This slide deck is located HERE. The slides reference the “Docket,” the suggested action steps that the Commission has compiled. The Commission refers to each action step as a “line” in the Docket. The Docket is located HERE.
During this meeting, the Commission took initial votes on many of the lines included in the Docket. The notes below will indicate the slide number from the main deck, as well as the line number for each vote.
I. Call to Order and Opening Remarks
Senator Amabile called the meeting to order at 9:11 am
Amabile acknowledged the length of the agenda for the day and said that they would likely not make it through every item included in the Docket. There will also be much fine-tuning of recommendations still to come. She thanked the commission facilitator, Summer Gathercole, for her excellent work in preparing materials for this stage of the meeting. Senator Kirkmeyer echoed these thanks and thanked Amabile for her leadership of the Commission.
II. Agenda Overview and Background Discussion
The Commission Facilitator reviewed the process for this decision-making stage and the agenda for the day. (See slides 2-20.) Senator Mullica expressed frustration that cost or cost-savings estimates are not available for most items the Commission will consider. The Commission will plan to existing laws, despite expected changes resulting from the recent election. Many budget parameters are still unknown because of a change in governor and passage of Amendment 87 and Proposition NN. While these new funding sources may provide additional “breathing room,” they do not solve the immediate issue of exponential growth in Medicaid costs. Representative Taggart and Senator Kirkmeyer expressed concern that the Governor’s budget does not address over half of the expected shortfall for Medicaid. Representative Brown echoed this sentiment: the long-term sustainability of Medicaid remains a necessary goal for the Commission.
The Commission will vote on each line in the docket. Seven votes are required to move a recommendation forward. (More details on slide 12.)
The Department of Health Care Policy and Finance (HCPF) flagged that 8 lines (suggested actions) are legally limited. (See slides 15-17.) The facilitator did not remove these items from the Docket. Rather, she provided some options for these items that would be permissible. Ultimately the decision about each item will be made by the Commission.
Senator Bridges stated his frustration with the lack of cost estimates and requested that if possible that these be generated prior to finalization of the report. Gathercole stated that she does not believe that is possible given timing and staff limitations. Amabile said that the Commission will set direction for actions, which may be modified should the cost be too high or savings not borne out. Mullica called the lack of cost-out a “failure.” Kirkmeyer stated that the Joint Budget Committee starts meeting this Thursday, and that HCPF should expect requests for cost-outs of some recommendations from that Committee.
III. Review of Long-term Items with Consensus Discussion
The Commission began taking action on items that are long-term in nature, specifically those for which Commission members have already indicated a high level of consensus.
Line 96: Addresses the Behavioral Health Ombudsman Office and redirects resources to other proactive accountability structures and consumer protections. (Slide 22.) The Commission had no objection to the suggested wording on the slide. Brown moved to adopt Line 96 with suggested wording. No objections. (Motion passes.)
Line 115: Independent evaluation of moving Medicaid pharmacy administration to a single state-directed administrator. (Slide 23.) Mullica requested that the line also include an examination of how Ohio and other states do this. Brown moved to adopt Line 115, with Mullica’s request included. No objection.
Line 14: Require a reconciliation of every major Medicaid policy change’s fiscal note savings claim against actual results. (Slides 24-25.) The facilitator proposed rewording based on feedback received from Commission (on slide 25). Mullica requested that the Commission (should it continue) and healthcare committees from both houses be added as recipients of the report. Sirota wants to make sure that the report be useful in timing and purpose to those that need it. This report could be useful quarterly, or when an outlier (overspend) occurs. Taggart asked for some disaggregation of the medical services line so that individual programs be better monitored. Brown moved to adopt a revised line 14. No objections.
Line 73a: Consider merging the Colorado Department of Human Services (CDHS) and HCPF. (Slide 26.) Brown moved to reject line 73a. No objections.
Line 51: Draw on unclaimed property trust fund to replace the reduced provider fee in coming years. (Slide 26.) Brown moved to reject line 51. No objection.
Line 72a: Institute a hard growth cap on HCPF expenditures. (Slide 27.) HCPF staff indicates that this action would be illegal because Medicaid is an entitlement. Brown moved to reject line 72a. Passed 7-1, with Bridges objecting.
Line 72b: Grandfather current rates and apply any new reduction to new enrollees only. (Slide 28.) Brown moved to reject Line 72 b. No objections.
Line 72c: Require legislative approval when a service category grows more than a set percentage in a year. (Slide 29.) Brown moved to reject 72c. Passed 6-2, with Brown and Frizzel objecting.
IV. Review of Remaining Long-term Items
The Commission went on to consider other long-term items for which there was not already consensus.
Line 107: Establish a guiding principle that HCPF covers as many people as possible but with fewer benefits as necessary to balance the budget. (Slide 31.) The facilitator asked members for a check-in on the priority of covering as many people as possible. Kirkmeyer said that this priority is not realistic without any fiscal guardrails. The priority ought to be on those who are medically frail or who are the poorest of the poor. We cannot cover everyone. Sirota reframed the statement to say that we ought not remove coverage from those who need it but maximize our coverage for those who need it. Mullica echoed this statement and added that the federal government sets guidelines for who qualifies for Medicaid. Gilchrist suggested rewording and argued that having a “north star” is important. She supports making sure that the people who need coverage have coverage. Additional specificity as to who needs coverage could be helpful. Brown suggested the addition of language such as “within the confines of federal guidelines,” and “within existing fiscal constraints.” Bridges said he has heard from constituents that they would prefer to keep more people in the program but with fewer benefits. He would also like to consider reducing the income caps. Kirkmeyer expressed concern with spreading resources too thin across too many people. Brown moved to adopt 107 with modified language to include everyone eligible covered and benefits narrowed rather than covering more people. Barron, Taggert, Kirkmeyer, Frizzell objected. Adopted.
Line 112: Repeal all state changes to Medicaid since 2019, as permissible. (Slide 33.) Based on feedback from the Commission, the Facilitator suggested to change this line to start with a review of each change and then repeal or modify as needed permitted. Brown moved to adopt line 112 with suggested changes. Mullica requested the addition of projected cost savings in the analysis. Barron concurred. No objections to adopting Line 112 with the addition of cost savings.
Line 85: Replace and modify the eligibility cliff for people leaving Medicaid. (Slide 33.) The facilitator suggested rewording to take into account feedback from Commission members. Kirkmeyer requested that the analysis include identification of sources of funding, state or federal. State-only funding would be problematic because of TABOR. Mullica concurred. Brown moved to adopt line 85 with added language re: cost and source of funding. No objections.
Line 33: Put CHIP, Cover All Coloradans, and optional benefit levels and eligibility thresholds on the Docket for consideration by the Commission rather than by the Joint Budget Committee (JBC). (Slide 34.) The facilitator suggested rewording, based on feedback from members, that this task be directed at the JBC. Taggart said that if not the JBC, then who would review? Sirota said she does not see this line as necessary because the JBC already does this. Brown moved to reject line 33. No objections.
Line 35: Cap benefits for the expansion population. (Slide 35-36.) Suggested rewording, based on feedback from members, added a trigger to do this only when costs for this item exceed available CHASE funds. Kirkmeyer asked if differentiated benefits for expansion population is permissible. Brown answered that yes, there is some flexibility. Gathercole asked HCPF to answer. Adela Flores-Brennan, HCPF Medicaid Director, said yes, it’s legal, but doing so would be challenging to manage. Brown moved to reject line 34. No objections.
Line 16a: Publish Medicaid actuarial assumptions on a dashboard. (Slides 37-38.) Suggested wording to account for feedback from the Commission identifies specific figures to include. Gilchrist had several questions, including whether HCPF would be strained by this task. Sirota stated that she doubts this line is cost neutral as stated. Brown moved to adopt line 16a with suggested wording changes. No objections.
Line 40: Continue the Commission, though with some changes. (Slide 39.) Mullica stated that he does not agree with the addition of members beyond legislators. Kirkmeyer concurred and asked about any oversight role that the Commission would have. Amabile said that this line would require a bill and that some details could be hashed out in that process. Taggart advocated in favor of adding non-legislators to the Commission because of how hospitals are going to be impacted by the coming decreases in CHASE fees. Sirota suggested that there be some limit on how long the Commission remains in place. Some continuation is necessary, however, to ensure follow-through as recommendations are implemented. Mullica suggested that the line include parameters on the Commission’s authority to request and obtain information. Brown moved to adopt line 40, striking including non-legislators and addition of defining authority of the Commission. No objections.
Line 15a – Define outcome measures for every Medicaid program and contract, and publish these outcomes in an annual report. Include an automatic wind down for those programs and contracts not performing. Members expressed concern about an automatic wind down. Kirkmeyer asked about what outcome measures to consider. Amabile called up HCPF Interim Executive Director Gretchen Hammer, who shared some examples of outcomes across several types of programs. The Commission and Hammer discussed the usefulness of more reporting as opposed to better reporting from HCPF. Brown moved to reject 15a. Motion failed. Bridges said that there is some need to identify when programs are not working. Gathercole suggested that the Commission table this until next week. Taggart objected to tabling the line. Taggart stated that HCPF has the obligation to report up to the Commission, JBC, legislature, etc., in a way that is usable. Brown moved 15a with revised language. 15a passed with Sirota objecting.
Line 19: Reduce the number of RAEs and BHASOs. (Slide 42-43.) Amabile said that she would like some investigation into whether or not Colorado’s number of RAEs and how they are organized is the optimal setup. She would like to better understand if what we are doing is the best way to do it. Kirkmeyer concurred and said that this decision cannot be made until we decide what to do with the Behavioral Health Administration (BHA). Brown concurred with the need for an evaluation of the current RAE setup before reducing the number of RAEs. Taggart asked that the Commission consider the differences in economies of scale between rural and urban areas in this decision. Brown moved to adopt line 19 with revisions, to include an examination of the appropriateness of how Colorado’s RAEs are set up. Line 19 passes 8-1 with Taggart objecting and Frizzell excused
Line 108: Tie a larger share of Medicaid payments to value and outcomes. (Slide 44.) Mullica asked if Hammer could answer whether or not this is already done. Hammer identified several ways in which value-based payments already occur. Amabile asked Hammer to identify the percent currently tied to outcomes. Hammer said that there is some variation, and that data is mixed on whether or not this sort of setup works to improve outcomes or save costs. The Commission continued to discuss how to keep this option open for instances in which it would be useful, but not a mandate across the board. Brown moved to adopt a revised Line 108. No objections.
Line 90: Standardize care management practice and payment across the RAEs and explore whether to differentiate case management for adults and children. (Slides 45-46.) Gilchrist said that this is worth exploring, but that caution needs to be taken to be sure that children are cared for. Bridges highlighted that pediatric care is different than care for adults and likely should be managed differently. Brown moved to adopt 90, with language changed to “Standardize care management practice across the RAES,” and to take into account whether it saves costs. No objections.
Line 43: Move behavioral health payments to a state-administered structure. (Slides 47-48.) Hammer stated that HCPF does similar for payments with dental. Doing so for behavioral health would end managed-care by RAE’s for behavioral health. Brown moved to reject line 43. No objections.
Line 92: End capitated managed care for behavioral health. (Slides 49-50.) Amabile said that she believes the capitated system for behavioral health is inherently unfair to those with serious illnesses. Other lines that will come before the Commission could address this concern. Brown moved to adopt a revised Line 92 to compare a capitated managed care model and fee for service model for behavioral health and have HCPF cost out and recommend which would work better. Mullica expressed that he would like to see behavioral health remain as capitated managed care and move physical health in that direction. Tabled until later conversation about managed care for physical health.
Line 7a: Consolidate care coordination for behavioral health. (Slides 51-53.) While members acknowledged the need to simplify care coordination, how to go about this depends on what they end up doing with the BHA. Changed to “simplify care coordination at the member level.” Brown moved to adopt Line 7a with modifications. No objections.
Line 18: Move the BHA’s Medicaid payment and contracting functions into HCPF. (Slides 54-55.) Amabile suggested additional changes: focus BHA on highest-acuity patients; focus care coordination only on high-acuity patients; keep as a separate entity. Amabile is working on a bill to make these changes. The Commission discussed additional ways in which they could modify the BHA. Eliminating duplicative programs should be a priority. Brown moved Line 18, modified to include taking steps to “right-size” the BHA, avoid duplication between the BHA and HCPF, and ensure there is a statewide system of care for behavioral health. No objections.
Lines 73 b and 94. (Slides 56-58.) Line 73b is not needed due to the Commission’s decision on Line 18. Line 94 will be folded into Line18.
Line 121: Create an Office of Recovery. (Slides 58-59.) HCPF noted that this office would not be permitted under federal law. The facilitator offered alternative wording to include people in recovery and peer support counselors are included on some advisory committees. Brown moved to reject line 121. No objection.
Line 31: Move Long-Term Services and Supports toward an individual budget model. (Slides 60-61.) This would eventually lead to consolidating 9 waivers into a single waiver. Brown moved to adopt Line 31 with suggested wording. No objections.
Line 48: Contract with Agencies on Aging to deliver community-based services for older adults. (Slide 62.) Brown moved to reject Line 48. No objections
Line 78: Create one accountable LTSS structure through a Governor’s Office of LTSS or a senior advisor to the Governor. (Slides 63-64.) Brown moved to reject Line 78. No objections.
Line 88: Sunset Community First Choice (CFC). (Slides 65-66.) The facilitator suggested rewording based on feedback from members: Maintain CFC, but identify what is driving its growth and set guardrails. Kirkmeyer suggested a pause in CFC and return of services to the waivers. Taggart stated that the Commission never saw the data that to identify the growth drivers in CFC. He would like the data. Kirkmeyer said that the Commission has received data showing growth in personal care and homemaker services. Brown said that he is not certain that you can “pause” a program like this. You can either scale the benefits back or end the program. Perhaps the Commission could come up with a way to limit benefits while it studies the cost drivers. Gilchrist said that she supports the suggested wording. Mullica has concerns with a “pause” but also acknowledges that exponential growth is not sustainable. Amabile stated that any “pause” would require a transition to other services for families and individuals who need them. Brown moved to adopt Line 88 with suggested language, and with the caveats that transition plans be established to maintain care in the least restrictive setting and development of measurable outcomes. Hammer came to the front to clarify details about CFC. She said that much of what has driven the increase in cost has been increased payment rates. Pausing the services in CFC would be technically challenging, and these services are life-saving services. HCPF is comfortable with the suggested recommendation and has already started acting. She will share the plans for this action at the Commission’s next meeting on November 18. Taggart said that he was okay with tabling Line 88 until that time. Brown withdraws motion. Line 88 tabled until November 18.
Line 125: Create a Medicaid prescribed pediatric extended care benefit or pilot. (Slide 67.) Brown moved to reject Line 125. No objections.
Line 127: Move LTSS into capitated care or other LTSS delivery system. (Slides 68-69.) The facilitator suggested alternative wording that would change the line to an evaluation of a capitated model for LTSS. Brown moved to reject line 127. Sirota agrees with motion because this may not be the best use of the Commission’s time. No objections.
The Commission discussed hospital financing, CHASE fees, and upcoming limits to these fees. (Slides 70-81.) Brown suggested a modification of recommendations to put together a working group of technical experts to advise on how to manage the reduction in CHASE fees. Gilchrist and Mullica agree. Mullica said that timeliness is important on this issue. Discussion of merging lines 56 and 11. (Slides 72-74.) Kirkmeyer advocated that hospitals be included as partners in this decision-making process. Sirota and Amabile concurred and stated they do not yet have the information needed to make a decision on this issue. Director Hammer shared that HCPF is working with the Colorado Hospital Association (CHA) on identifying a solution to CHASE fee reductions and impact on hospitals. HCPF and CHA are in agreement that they cannot yet make a change to their model until they have sufficient information. HCPF supports line 11. (Slide 74.) Brown moved suggested wording for line 11 with modifications. No objections.
Line 56: Implement AHEAD-style multi-payer model for rural hospitals. (Slides 72-73.) Kirkmeyer asked for an explanation of this model. Brown moved to adopt Line 56 with suggested wording and additional modifications. Amabile expressed concern with this being a pilot. She would rather see a complete roll out across the state. No objections.
Line 20: Employer contribution to Medicaid for their workers who are on Medicaid. Brown moved to reject line 20. Passed with 3 objections: Mullica, Sirota, and Bridges.
Line 21: Implement a commercial payment corridor for hospital payments. (Slide 76.) Brown moved to reject Line 21. Passed with 3 objections: SIrota, Brown, and Bridges.
Line 50: Inventory local public funds and pursue a federal match where allowed. (Slide 77.) Amabile asked, “Who is going to do this?” Taggart said that he does not understand this item, but if it ends up with an unfunded mandate for local governments, he will not support it. Brown moved to reject Line 50. No objections.
Line 52: Raise the excise tax on alcohol and dedicate revenue for Substance Use Disorder (SUD) treatment and Medicaid. Brown moved to reject Line 52. No objections. Bridges expressed concern that this is the only revenue-generating item the Commission has considered.
V. Review of Short-term Items
The Commission started to consider short-term action items.
Line 12: Institute additional member cost sharing structures instead of coverage reductions. (Slide 79.) HR1 does mandate some cost sharing, but CO is already meeting this requirement. Brown moved to reject line 12. Passed with 4 objecting : Kirkmeyer, Frizzell, Amabile, and Mullica.
Line 32: Benchmark optional benefits against the national midline. (Slide 79.) Brown moved to accept Line 31 with the following modification: “Review where Colorado’s benefits are for other states, relying on outside partners, like NCSL.” No objections.
Line 64: Institute a waitlist before new out-of-state arrivals access waivers. (Slide 80.) HCPF staff indicate that federal law bars waitlists based on length of residency. Brown moved to reject Line 64. No objections.
Line 109: Make enrolling and re-enrolling in Medicaid as easy as possible. (Slide 81.) Commission members acknowledged that this Line is not very specific, but streamlining enrollment and eligibility processes and infrastructure is needed. They would like platforms to share information as much as possible. Mullica cited some examples from other states that Colorado could adopt. Frizzell shared that she met with a group from the state IT department that is working on items like this. Brown moved to adopt Line 109. No objections. Brown moved to include best practices from what other states are doing to Line 109. No objections.
Line 13c: Fund appeals capacity before HR1 volume arrives. Suggested re-wording included. (Slide 81.) This item is already included in the proposed state budget for FY27-28. HCPF staff indicated that moving through appeals faster will save costs. Brown moved to accept Line 13c with suggested wording. Hammer stated that appeals have more than doubled over last year. HCPF is conducting a root cause analysis to determine why this is happening. No objections.
Line 29: Raise disability buy-in premiums. (Slide 81.) Sirota would need to see what this looks like before approving – who is impacted and income levels impacted. Amabile and Barron concur. Brown moves to approve line 29 with suggested language. HCPF will investigate raising premiums. No objections.
Line 35: Institute continuous authorization and work-requirement safeguards. (Slide 82.) Amabile asked if HR1 would permit this, even with suggested changes. Flores-Brennan said that yes, some safeguards could be permitted for some individuals, but HCPF is not certain on how to do this in light of HR1. Brown moves to reject Line 35. No objections
Line 36: Reassess and reset non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) rural classification and rates. (Slide 82.) Mullica would like cost estimates before moving forward. Sirota is skeptical about the cost-neutral classification of this Line. Amabile argued that rates are the job of the JBC. Taggart does not disagree, but he is proposing for HCPF to revert to their budget proposal because the western slope is losing NEMT providers. Mullica argued in favor of having the JBC consult with Commission members in setting these rates. Brown moved to adopt Line 36, with modifications, and adding “understanding the impacts of costs.” Brown withdrew the motion. Taggart stated that this issue needs a long-term solution. Brown moved Line 36 as previously moved. No objections.
Line 63: Raise the long-term care asset limit. (Slide 83.) Members requested that the Line include an assessment of the cost. Hammer stated that costs would be incurred because more people would become eligible for long-term care. She offered to bring some cost analysis to the next meeting. Brown moved to table Line 63. No objections.
Line 74: Fix CHP+ to Medicaid transitions. (Slide 83.) The Commission will hold off consideration of this line until next week’s meeting.
Line 76: Institute one redetermination per year for waiver members. (Slide 84.) The Commission will hold off consideration of this line until next week’s meeting.
Line 87: Institute a sliding scale parental fee for children on waivers or CFC. HCPF staff indicates that this Line conflicts with several Social Security regulations. Brown moved to adopt modified wording for 87. No objections. HCPF will bring back any options for parental cost sharing at the Commission’s next meeting.
VI. Report Back
The Facilitator will generate a revised Docket based on today’s meeting and starting draft of report prior to next week’s Commission meeting.
Commission members stated their approval of the process used in today’s meeting and emphasized their frustration with a lack of cost data from HCPF.
VII. Public Testimony
The Commission heard testimony from 7 individuals. These include providers and representatives of provider agencies, including a peer support service provider and an adaptive recreation provider; parent caregivers; and representatives of advocacy organizations. Topics covered included:
- Peer support services
- Long-term support services
- Community First Choice
- Adaptive recreation
- Transparency for PASAs
- Final report recommendations
VIII. Adjourn
Senator Amabile adjourned the meeting 4:19 pm.

Policy Perspective is a publication of ADVOCACYDENVER. If you have any questions, please contact Paul Baumann, Policy Outreach Specialist, at pbaumann@advocacydenver.org or 303.974.2535.